The Idaho Supreme Court and Idaho Court of Appeals cited opinions are made available on the Internet as a public service. All cited opinions are posted the day of their release. West Publishing Company publishes all cited opinions in the Pacific Reporter and Idaho Reports volumes. All cited opinions are removed from this site upon release of the published volume.

NOTICE: These opinions are subject to formal revision before publication in the preliminary print of the Pacific Reporter. Readers are requested to notify the Clerk of the Court/Reporter of Decisions, Supreme Court of Idaho, Boise, Idaho, 83720-0101, of any typographical or other formal errors, in order that corrections may be made before the preliminary print goes to press.

Idaho Court of Appeals Opinions - Civil

List of Idaho Court of Appeals civil opinions by release date:

  1. April 30, 2012 – Raymond Scott Peck v. Dept of Transportation – License suspension     
  2. April 25, 2012 – Health & Welfare v. Jane (2011-17) Doe – Termination of parental rights     
  3. April 17, 2012 – Amber Rose Markwood v. Joshua Robert Markwood – Child custody     
  4. April 10, 2012 – Linda Lee Hubbard v. Dept of Transportation – License suspension     
  5. March 16, 2012 – Health & Welfare v. John Doe – Termination of parental rights     
  6. January 6, 2012 – John Bach v. Wayne Dawson and Katherine Miller – Appeal from entry of default judgment     
  7. November 17, 2011 –Rebecca S. Wilkinson v. State Dept of Transportation – License suspension     
  8. November 3, 2011 – Richard Naranjo v. Idaho Department of Correction – Appeal from dismissal of tort action for alleged injury during incarceration     
  9. October 21, 2011 – Hamish Allan Bell v. Idaho Transportation Department – License suspension     
  10. August 26, 2011 – Randolf L. Burghart v. Terema Carlin – Appeal from dismissal of writ of habeas corpus     
  11. July 27, 2011 – Health & Welfare v. John Doe – Termination of parental rights     
  12. July 1, 2011 – McCormack v. Caldwell – Attorney malpractice claim     
  13. June 7, 2011 – Termination of parental rights (father) John Doe     
  14. May 27, 2011 – Idaho Transportation v. Johnathan Paul Van Comp – License Suspension     
  15. May 5, 2011 – County of Twin Falls v. Eric Hettinga – Zoning ordinance – property use     
  16. April 27, 2011 – Jana S.A. Moffett v. Brian S. Moffett – Divorce settlement     
  17. April 19, 2011 – James Kevin Buell v. Department of Transportation – License suspension     
  18. March 30, 2011 – Elizabeth Antim v. Fred Meyer Stores / Cleaning Services Group – Personal injury action     
  19. March 10, 2011 – Ryan J. Rodriguez v. Belinda Alexia Rodriguez – Custody modification     
  20. March 3, 2011 – Re Termination of Parental Rights (father) – H&W v. John Doe III     
  21. March 2, 2011 – Kristina Drinkall v. Darren Drinkall – Custody / child support modification    
  22. February 2, 2011 – Scott Thomas Cunningham v. State of Idaho – Driver’s license suspension    
  23. January 26, 2011 – George Davidson v. Jesyca Hood Davidson – Appeal from dismissal and summary judgment of complaints for alleged slander, emotional distress, conspiracy    
  24. December 20, 2010 – Gale Lee Masterson v. Idaho Dept of Transportation – Driver’s license suspension    
  25. December 20, 2010 – In the Matter of Terminating Parental Rights (father)    
  26. December 14, 2010 – State v. Matilda K. Kling – Driver’s license suspension    SUBSTITUTE
  27. December 10, 2010 – State v. Matilda K. Kling – Driver’s license suspension    WITHDRAWN
  28. November 7, 2010 – State v. Two Jinn, Inc. /Brett Robert Bardsley – Motion to set aside forfeiture and exonerate bond   
  29. November 4, 2010 – Health & Welfare v. John Doe I and Jane Doe II – Decree of protective custody   
  30. September 30, 2010 – Todd Allen Butters v. Phillip Valdez, et al. – Appeal from summary judgment granted in favor of defendants in inmate’s grievance claims   
  31. September 13, 2010 – Britt Colleen Burton v. State Department of Transportation – Suspension of driver’s license   
  32. August 26, 2010 – Bryan Lee McDaniel v. State Department of Transportation – Suspension of driver’s license     AMENDED 8/27/2010
  33. August 9, 2010 – Health & Welfare v. Jane Doe II and John Doe II – Termination of parental rights   
  34. August 5, 2010 – William Lightner and Marcia Lightner v. John Hardison   
  35. August 4, 2010 – Health & Welfare v. Jane Doe I – Termination of parental rights   
  36. July 27, 2010 – Health & Welfare v. John Doe II and Jane Doe II – Termination of parental rights   
  37. July 9, 2010 – Bruce Tiegs v. Darrell L. Robertson and Dustin M. Kukla - Negligence   
  38. June 9, 2010 – Health & Welfare v. Jane Doe II – Termination of parental rights   
  39. June 1, 2010 – State of Idaho v. Michael Howard Wagner – Suspension of driver’s license  
  40. May 19, 2010 – State of Idaho v. Two Jinn, Inc./Rosendo Arriago Navarro – Motion to set aside forfeiture  
  41. May 7, 2010 – In the Matter of Termination of Parent-Child Relationship – State Dept. of H&W v. Jane Doe 
  42. April 15, 2010 – In the Matter of Termination of Parent-Child Relationship – State Dept. of H&W v. Jane Doe 
  43. April 7, 2010 – State of Idaho v. Two Jinn, Inc./Aaron Kyle Harris – Motion to set aside forfeiture and exonerate bond
  44. March 30, 2010 – In the Matter of Jane Doe, a minor child, Health & Welfare v. Jane Doe I – Termination of parental rights   SUBSTITUTE
  45. March 25, 2010 – Medical Recovery Services, LLC. v. Billy M. Carnes – Action to collect unpaid medical expenses
  46. March 15, 2010 – State of Idaho v. Two Jinn, Inc./Roderick Jay Brown – Motion to set aside forfeiture and exonerate bond
  47. March 4, 2010 – Total Success Investments v. Ada County Highway District / Washington Mutual Bank - Encroachment
  48. March 4, 2010 – State v. Two Jinn/  Larry Grant Dana, Jr. -Motion to set aside forfeiture and exonerate bond  SUBSTITUTE
  49. February 26, 2010 –– State v. Two Jinn/  Larry Grant Dana, Jr. -Motion to set aside forfeiture and exonerate bond  WITHDRAWN
  50. November 25, 2009 – Paul William Driggers v. Amanda Grafe / Dept. of H & W – Dismissal of tort claim in child custody case
  51. November 4, 2009 –Leann Craig v. Steven John Gellings – Personal injury action - auto accident
  52. October 15, 2009 – David Oliver Wheeler v. Idaho Transportation Department – Driving under the influence
  53. October 15, 2009 – Gary Alan Feasel v. Idaho Transportation Department – Driving under the influence
  54. August 24, 2009 – Lerajjareanra-O-Kelly v. Mark Schow – Appeal from order denying fee waiver
  55. August 14, 2009 – Susan Carol Olson v. Marvin Raynell Montoya – Divorce; child support
  56. May 1, 2009 – State of Idaho v. John Doe – Reimbursement of detention cost
  57. April 30, 2009 – Gordon C. Schroeder v. Department of Transportation – Suspension of license
  58. April 28, 2009 – Sunnyside Industrial and Professional Park, LLC v. Eastern Idaho Public Health Dist. – Appeal from order denying motion for attorney fees  
  59. April 8, 2009 – Curtis “Jay” Johnson v. Mike McPhee and JCAV, LLC – Breach of contract, negligence 
  60. April 2, 2009 – Stacie Dawn Bennett v. Idaho Dept. of Transportation – Suspension of license 
  61. March 31, 2009 – State of Idaho v. John Doe, In the Interest of John Doe, A Minor Child - Curfew
  62. February 5, 2009 – Frederick Earl Lawrence v. Keith E. Hutchinson –Legal malpractice
  63. November 14, 2008 – Robert J. Carlson v. Brandon M. Stanger – Auto accident; personal injury
  64. November 14, 2008 – Evan Edward Morgan, Jr. v. Sexual Offender Classification Board – Appeal from an order for VSP designation
  65. November 3, 2008 – Rodney Peterson v. William R. Shore – Property contract dispute
  66. September 25, 2008 – In the Interest of Jane Doe, A Child Under 18 Years of Age: City Code Violation - Curfew
  67. August 14, 2008 – Action Collection v. Matthew Haught and Chapman Enterprises, Inc. – Rental agreement
  68. July 31, 2008 – Todd Robert Briggs v. Warden Kevin Kempf, ICI-O – Prisoner civil rights complaint
  69. July 21, 2008 – Nguyen v. Bui and Mongo Grill – Breach of written agreement
  70. July 16, 2008 – Marina Harris v. Austin Roger Carter – Child custody
  71. July 2, 2008 – Jeanette M. McKoon v. David Lynn Hathaway – Divorce decree real property award
  72. June 27, 2008 – Action Collection Services, Inc. v. Cindy Bigham – Complaint to collect including attorney fees and costs
  73. June 24, 2008 – Juan Manuel Cuevas v. Bernardino Barraza and Liobaldo Garza – Real property dispute
  74. June 9, 2008 – State of Idaho v. John Doe – Denial of restitution for medical expenses
  75. April 14, 2008 – Susan J. Beehler v. Fremont County – Complaint alleging negligence against Fremont County Sheriff’s Department
  76. March 27, 2008 – Idaho Transportation Dept. v. Frank Albert Archer – Suspended driver’s license
  77. February 22, 2008 – Boots v. Winters – Common law negligence
  78. January 29, 2008 – Douglas Joel Aho v. Idaho Transportation Dept. – Suspended driver’s license
  79. December 24, 2007 – Richard Drennon v. Idaho State Correctional Institution – Appeals the district court’s dismissal of amended complaint
  80. December 10, 2007 – Medical Recovery Services, LLC v. Jones, Sharon – Attorney fee award
  81. October 24, 2007 – Rickey L. Ross v. Susan Clarke Ross – Appeals post-judgment ruling of trial court declining an award of prejudgment interest on restitutionary damages
  82. June 20, 2007 – James W. Berry v. Ed Ostrom – Motion to dismiss for lack of an accounting re partnership-related debt dispute
  83. May 31, 2007 – Leodegario Cruz Martinez v. Kelly D. Brown – Appeal from the district court’s dismissal of negligence action
  84. May 24, 2007 – Mary C. Curlee v. Kootenai County Fire & Rescue – Wrongful termination - order granting motion for summary judgment
  85. April 19, 2007 – Darrel McCabe v. Olivia Craven, et al. – Order summarily dismissing complaint alleging state tort claims and 42 U.S.C. § 1983 claim
  86. December 13, 2006 – Western Corporation v. Stan L. Vanek – Judgment obtained in 1997 against Vanek and effect of provision stating that the judgment was entered "nunc pro tunc"
  87. November 14, 2006 – State of Idaho, Department of Transportation v. Marvin Gibbar – Suspension of driver’s license following failure to pass blood alcohol concentration test
  88. July 18, 2006 – Cobi Straub v. Donald R. Smith and Leslie Smith – Motion for reconsideration and dismissal

Judiciary Home | Back to Opinions Page